The New Zealand Automobile Association identifies the following points to consider when deciding whether diesel, petrol or LPG is the right choice for you.
How far will the vehicle travel?
Diesel may be the cheaper option if you travel a large number of kilometres per year. Alternatively, if you travel 15,000km or less per year, petrol or LPG may be the best option for you.
The size and type of vehicle
SUVs and other large cars have higher fuel consumption – and so diesel power is often best. Small petrol or LPG cars (less than 1.6 L) will likely be very efficient.
According to the AA (Automobile Association), diesel cars usually travel up to 30 per cent further on a tank of fuel.
Traditionally diesel vehicles have been significantly more expensive to buy than petrol cars. Alternatively, converting your petrol car to LPG can be expensive – something to consider when choosing LPG as an option. Remember that while you have little control over the eventual running costs, you may be able to negotiate the purchase price of your vehicle.
Petrol models of large 4WD vehicles often depreciate faster than the diesel models.
Diesel remains cheaper at the pump, despite rises in all fuel prices. Road user charges (RUC) and higher registration charges need to be considered also. LPG can be up to 60 per cent cheaper than petrol, litre for litre.
Road User Charges
RUC applies to:
- All cars, such as those running on diesel, that are not taxed at source
- All vehicles over 3.5 tonnes – regardless of fuel type
This fee is fixed – regardless of the distance travelled. Costs can vary depending on vehicle class, designation and fuel type.
Service and maintenance costs
Traditionally, diesel vehicles have been more costly to service. Now the difference may be less, as modern diesel-powered vehicles don’t require servicing as often as in the past – though this depends on the manufacturer’s recommendations. Note that LPG engines have a potentially longer engine life.
Noise and performance
Older diesel engines tend to be noisier, but this isn’t such an issue with modern vehicles. Modern common rail diesel engines need clean fuel, so refuelling at busy stations is advised – the higher turnover means the fuel isn’t sitting around for long. By contrast, refuelling from a diesel tank on a farm is not advised. Generally, LPG engines are not as powerful as petrol or diesel.
No engines are good for the environment. Both diesel and petrol powered vehicles emit a range of pollutants. Arguably, a diesel vehicle causes less pollution than its petrol equivalent. However, LPG engines have reduced exhaust emissions in comparison to petrol and diesel.
Car yard discounts and resale
Discounts at the car yard on both diesel and petrol powered vehicles are common, and it’s cheaper to buy an ex-demonstrator model. Service plans are also becoming more common, and are often factored into the initial price – something else to consider. Resale prices can also favour diesel, petrol or LPG, depending on where the market demand is.
Ready to buy a car? Here are four tips on what to say when you're talking with the seller.